Last Friday evening, I gave a public lecture as part of the Philosophy in the Community Lecture and Discussion Series hosted by the University of Saskatchewan’s Philosophy Department. The talk explored agency in the context of the climate crisis. To close, I invited the audience to participate in a brief exercise that asked them to call to mind a part of the natural world that matters in a personal way, to consider the emotions that arise when we reflect on our relationship with nature, and to discuss in small groups what it feels like to care about a part of nature whose future we cannot control.
The conversations that followed were revealing. One participant spoke about the contradictions in his own life, recalling tree planting in his youth, followed by a turn to mining when earning a living became a necessity. Others described places affected by wildfires. Some spoke about large bodies of water that seemed inseparable from their understanding of themselves and their place in the world. The conversations continued longer than I'd anticipated, and bringing everyone back together proved surprisingly difficult. People were engaged, listening to one another and sharing experiences that carried considerable personal significance.
There was no resolution to the feelings that emerged, nor did we arrive at a shared understanding of what ought to happen next. One participant asked about the difference between hope and optimism, prompting a brief discussion of Rebecca Solnit's understanding of hope, which she believes persists as long as there is even a fraction of a percentage point of global warming we might yet prevent. I resisted the temptation to conclude with an encouraging message about the future. The questions we'd raised deserved consideration, even when resolution isn’t forthcoming.
I've been reflecting on the conversation in the days since. Did it make a difference? Did it constitute a form of action? I think it did, although I cannot know what, if anything, will follow for the people who participated. For me, the experience offered a reminder that people do indeed care about the climate crisis. They cared enough to spend a Friday evening listening to a philosophical lecture on the topic, to share personal experiences with strangers, and to think together about what it means to live with environmental uncertainty.
When Concern Looks Like Indifference
A few months ago, I was interviewed for a radio show by a man who seemed to carry an assumption that has stayed with me. He suggested that people aren't taking action on climate change because they don't care. It's a familiar sentiment, and one I can understand. Despite decades of scientific warnings and increasingly visible ecological destruction, the political and economic arrangements contributing to the crisis remain fixed. When our responses seem so inadequate to the scale of the problem, it is tempting to conclude that most people are indifferent about its consequences.
Yet my experience as a counsellor has increasingly led me to question that assumption. Climate-related distress comes up frequently in my work, sometimes alongside other concerns and sometimes as a significant source of anxiety, grief, anger, or helplessness. People may be deeply troubled by environmental destruction while struggling to understand what they can do about it. Their concerns may not become apparent in everyday behaviour, however, particularly when the circumstances of their lives offer limited opportunities to respond.
Australian environmental philosopher Glenn Albrecht offers a useful perspective through his concept of eco-paralysis. Albrecht (2011) suggests that what appears to be apathy or disengagement may reflect an inability to respond meaningfully to ecological problems that seem overwhelming and intractable. These problems are embedded in the economic, political, and social arrangements upon which our lives depend. We may recognize their destructive consequences while remaining reliant on the very systems we wish to change.
The person who shifts from tree planting to mining illustrates something of this difficulty. There is often a tension between environmental commitments and the economic necessities of everyday life. Although our circumstances and opportunities differ considerably, many of us encounter similar contradictions. Our apparent unwillingness to change may reveal relatively little about what we value or the difficulties we face in trying to live in alignment with those values.
Climate psychology researcher Panu Pihkala has examined how ecological concern can motivate engagement while at the same time contributing to experiences of overwhelm, exhaustion, and withdrawal (Kurth & Pihkala, 2022). When the problems confronting us seem immense, and our individual contributions appear insignificant, we may find ourselves questioning whether anything we do can make a difference. And if we believe that few others share our concerns, the possibility of collective action may seem even more remote. We may withdraw from conversations because we anticipate disagreement or dismissal, leaving our assumptions about others largely unexamined.
For me, this research motivates curiosity about whether the apparent absence of action tells us more about how we understand agency than about the extent of people's concern. We tend to evaluate our efforts according to whether they produce the outcomes we intend. Yet the climate crisis presents challenges that no individual can resolve, and even collective efforts unfold within circumstances that make their consequences uncertain. If we measure the significance of our participation primarily through its immediate outcomes, we may overlook other ways in which we influence the world we share.
Speech, Action, and the Possibility of Something New
In The Human Condition (1958), political philosopher Hannah Arendt develops an understanding of action that draws our attention toward what becomes possible through our participation with others. Central to her account is the concept of plurality, which describes the condition of sharing a world with others while each of us inhabits it from a distinct perspective. Our different experiences, histories, and relationships mean that we never understand the world in precisely the same way. Yet these differences also make it possible for us to encounter perspectives and possibilities that might never have occurred to us independently.
For Arendt, action takes place directly between people, particularly through speech and our participation in shared activities. Whatever we initiate enters an existing web of human relationships, where others may respond in ways we cannot anticipate. Our words may challenge someone's assumptions, provoke disagreement, introduce unfamiliar perspectives, or influence decisions and relationships that develop in unexpected directions. Because others are also capable of initiating action, what emerges through these encounters cannot be determined by any one participant alone.
Arendt describes our capacity to initiate something new through the concept of natality. Although the term refers to birth, its philosophical significance concerns the possibility of introducing something new into the world throughout our lives. Our participation takes place within circumstances that precede us, yet those circumstances are continually shaped through what people say and do. Even when established arrangements seem resistant to change, the actions of others can introduce possibilities that we could not have anticipated.
Speech has a particular significance within this account. Through speaking, we disclose something of ourselves to others, making our experiences and perspectives available for consideration. Arendt's understanding of action is explicitly political, and I wouldn't suggest that every conversation necessarily constitutes political action in her sense. Nevertheless, her account offers good reasons to take seriously what happens when people come together to speak about matters of shared concern. We cannot know in advance how others will receive what we say, what they might take from an encounter, or how their understanding might influence their subsequent participation in the world.
This understanding of speech and action has motivated my interest in creating opportunities for people to come together and discuss their experiences of the climate crisis. Throughout this year, I've been facilitating Climate Cafés, which are informal gatherings where people share their thoughts, feelings, and experiences concerning environmental change. These gatherings aren't therapy groups or political activism, and there is no expectation that participants arrive with solutions or leave feeling more hopeful. They offer an opportunity to speak openly about experiences that can be difficult to discuss elsewhere, particularly when we feel isolated in our concerns or uncertain about how to respond.
The conversations following last week's lecture were, by design, similar to those I've encountered in these gatherings. People spoke about places they love, contradictions they struggle with, and changes they can’t control. Their contributions revealed something about their relationships with the natural world that might otherwise have remained unspoken. In listening to one another, participants also encountered perspectives that could complicate their assumptions about how others experience the climate crisis.
I don't know whether anyone left with a different understanding of their responsibilities, a renewed commitment to environmental action, or even a greater sense of connection. Those possibilities remain open, but they aren't outcomes I can claim. What I took from the evening was a renewed appreciation for how little we may know about the concerns of those around us. The assumption that people don't care becomes harder to sustain when we create opportunities to hear what matters to them.
Of course, talking about the climate crisis cannot substitute for the political, economic, and material changes required to address it. Yet Arendt's account reminds us that our capacity to act is bound up with our relationships with others, and that what becomes possible through our participation cannot be fully anticipated. Perhaps there is something worth reconsidering in our tendency to dismiss conversations simply because we cannot measure their consequences. The people who gathered last Friday evening did not resolve the problems we discussed, but they participated in a shared examination of what those problems mean for their lives. I think that matters.
Our final Climate Café of 2026 will take place on Wednesday, November 25 at 7:00 PM. These gatherings are free and open to anyone who would like to participate. There is no need to arrive with answers or even a clear understanding of what you want to say. The invitation is to come together and make room for the experiences, perspectives, and questions that arise as we try to understand our place in a changing world.
References
Albrecht, G. (2011). Chronic environmental change: Emerging ‘psychoterratic’ syndromes. In I. Weissbecker (Ed.), Climate change and human well-being: Global challenges and opportunities (pp. 43–56). Springer.
Kurth, C., & Pihkala, P. (2022). Eco-anxiety: What it is and why it matters. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, 981814.
Books to Explore
Hannah Arendt, The Human Condition (1958). University of Chicago Press.
Glenn Albrecht, Earth Emotions: New Words for a New World (2019). Cornell University Press.
Rebecca Solnit, Hope in the Dark: Untold Histories, Wild Possibilities (2004). Nation Books.
Britt Wray, Generation Dread: Finding Purpose in an Age of Climate Crisis (2022). Alfred A. Knopf Canada.
Joanna Macy & Molly Young Brown, Coming Back to Life: The Updated Guide to the Work That Reconnects (2014). New Society Publishers.